Arca Rated

Arca Rated

8th best player outside the Premiership.

Re: Arca Rated

That poll made me laugh, Sheringham was voted 4th he has only played about ten games for the hammers, for the record on current form Arca would not be in my top 50

Thought Arca may of been higher

Re: Re: Arca Rated

If only MM would play him in his favorite postion, he would rock.

Re: Re: Re: Arca Rated

Yeah left back is his favoured positiion but in all honesty you could not drop George McCartney he is having a cracking season and is a real prospect.

Whats top 10 ???

Re: Re: Re: Re: Arca Rated

Word from the Scum in my office is that McCartney is great going forward but not so hot when it come's to defending? Can you confirm or deny this

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Arca Rated

Going forward there is not a better attacking full back in the division, defensivley he is solid enough but does not really get tested that often in this division. IF we go up we will find out just how good or poor his defending is.

Can someone post the list?

Ther you go mate


Top 50

1 Steve Sidwell (Reading)
2 Nathan Ellington (Wigan)
3 Darren Bent (Ipswich)
4 Teddy Sheringham (W Ham)
5 Jason Roberts (Wigan)
6 Danny Gabbidon (Cardiff)
7 Jimmy Bullard (Wigan)
8 Julio Arca (Sunderland)
9 Stuart Elliot (Hull)
10 Leighton Baines (Wigan)
11 David Healy (Leeds)
12 Phil Jagielka (Sheff U)
13 Lee Trundle (Swansea)
14 Nigel Reo-Coker (W Ham)
15 Paul McKenna (Preston)
16 Curtis Davies (Luton)
17 Ade Akinbiyi (Stoke)
18 Andy Lonergan (Preston)
19 Aaron Lennon (Leeds)
20 Leroy Lita (Bristol C)
21 Steve Howard (Luton)
22 John Halls (Stoke)
23 Lee Johnson (Yeovil)
24 Nick Barmby (Hull)
25 Sam Parkin (Swindon)
26 Daniel Harding (Brighton)
27 Phil Jevons (Yeovil)
28 Tom Huddlestone (Derby)
29 Lee Camp (Derby)
30 Paul Ince (Wolves)
31 Dean Windass (Bradford)
32 Dave Kitson (Reading)
33 Steven Elliot (Sunderland)
34 Iain Hume (Tranmere)
35 Luke Steele (Coventry)
36 Ryan Taylor (Tranmere)
37 Heider Helguson (Watford)
38 Leon Knight (Brighton)
39 Sam MacLean (Sheff W)
40 Nathan Clarke (Hud’field)
41 Danny Webber (Watford)
42 Paul Furlong (QPR)
43 Darren Currie (Ipswich)
44 Jamal Campbell-Ryce (Rotherham)
45 Paul Hayes (Scunthorpe)
46 John Ruddy (Cambridge)
47 David Vaughan (Crewe)
48 Richie Wellins (Blackpool)
49 David Noble (Boston)
50 Jamie Brooks (Oxford)

1. Steve Sidwell
2. Nathan Ellington
3. Darren Bent
4. Teddy Sheringham
5. Jason Roberts
6. Danny Gabbidon
7. Jimmy Bullard
8. Julio Arca
9. Stuart Elliott
10. Leighton Barnes
11. David Healy
12. Phil Jagielka
13. Lee Trundle
14. Nigel Reo-Coker
15. Paul McKenna
16. Curtis Davies
17. Ade Akibiyi (ha!)
18. Andy Lonergan
19. Aaron Lennon
20. Leroy Lita
21. Steve Howard
22. John Halls
23. Lee Johnson
24. Nick Barmby
25. Sam Parkin
26. Daniel Harding
27. Phil Jevons
28. Tom Huddlestone
29. Lee Camp
30. Paul Ince
31. Dean Windass
32. Dave Kitson
33. Stephen Eliott
34. Iain Hume
35. Luke Steele
36. Ryan Taylor
37. Heidar Helguson
38. Leon Knight
39. Steven Maclean
40. Nathan Clarke
41. Danny Webber
42. Paul Furlong
43. Darren Currie
44. Jamal Campbell-Ryce
45. Paul Hayes
46. John Ruddy
47. David Vaughan
48. Richie Wellens
49. David Noble
50. Jamie Brooks


------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wow what a great list.... :spangled:

where's Michale Tonge?

Good point he would be in my top 10

what a load of bollocks that list is

arca has been less than impresive this season to be honest.

Players,fans,managers & people from the media voted but the order was decided by 442 editorial staff. Most of the players who's lists were shown in the mag did pick former Arsenal player Sidwell as the best.